Drive-By Discernment

Why I’m answering

Recently a YouTube user called @mannajetzt posted this warning under one of my videos, addressed to “fellow believers testing this channel.” Over several days he set out his case at length, in an exchange with a brother from Scotland who answered him. (That brother isn’t me, but I will come back to him).

I’m answering this here and now because these charges are serious and were made in public, under my full name. If they were true, you should stop listening to me. So I’m going to set the record straight. I’ll show that this man hadn’t read what he condemned, that he misquoted the one document he did read, and that he did all of it without putting his name to it.

The verdict came before the reading

He told us exactly what he’d read. “No, I haven’t seen much of Nick’s content.” He read the transcript of one video, read our Confession, and watched the video he was commenting on.

The brother seeking to engage with him in good faith offered him more. He offered God Closed Church, (which is free-to-hear on my channel and website within the playlist), teaching on Jeremiah 24, my contact details, and a face-to-face (screen-to-screen) meeting. He turned it all down. “I don’t have enough time to delve more deeply.” And then: “I don’t need to finish the movie to see that the foundation is cracked.”

His charge is radicalisation. In 2023 I published a book called The Glorious Few, subtitled Redeeming Radicalisation in the Kingdom of God. It’s 250 pages on what biblical radicalisation is and what it isn’t. Much of what I’ve communicated since rests on it; but it wasn’t on his list, and he told us he had no time to go further.

So here’s the definition he never read. In that book I define being radicalised as “the individual root-level submission to the Lordship of Jesus Christ as evidenced by the full surrender of the person to the leading of the Holy Spirit into a loving head-on collision with the unsaved world.”

Notice the three things in that definition. It means submission to Christ, not to me. It means surrender to the Holy Spirit. And the collision it describes is a loving one, with the unsaved world, (including much of the landscape of the apostate Church), not with my genuine brothers. That is the “dangerous radicalisation” he warned the whole of YouTube about.

He opened with 1 Thessalonians 5:21: “Test all things; hold fast what is good.” Of course I agree with that, (Mairi and I discuss as such here); but you can’t test what you won’t read. He sampled three items and published a verdict on my teaching, my motives and my character. Then he left. That isn’t discernment. It’s a drive-by.

The one document he did read

He did read my Confession (above), and he quoted it. His very first comment says that in my Confession I label cessationism “spiritual adultery” and an “antichrist spirit.” He repeated it in his longer rebuttal, and he built his most serious charge on it.

Neither phrase is in my Confession. It’s on my website, dated the fourth of February 2026 and signed by Mairi and me. Read it for yourself. The word “adultery” doesn’t appear in it anywhere, and neither does “antichrist.” But you should read what I think about every idol of man, whether in or out of the Church. Spiritual adultery is the result of antichrist.

So he misquoted the one document he actually read, and didn’t exercise due diligence to come to learn where and why the charge of spiritual adultery is fair.

Here’s what the Confession actually says. It stands on the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds. It calls for repentance across the whole Church, not only in “other churches.” On the Holy Spirit, it rejects “the quenching of the Holy Spirit through the doctrinal denial of His continuing gifts.” It also criticises charismatic excess and says plainly: “The Church must repent on both sides.” That isn’t someone building a sect. It’s a call to the whole bride.

Names on the record

There’s something else you need to see, because it runs through this whole affair.

My name is on everything I communicate. It’s on the cover of my books, Nicholas Paul Franks, the same full name he used to warn people about. My face is on every video. Mairi’s name is beside mine at the bottom of the Confession. My contact details are on my website, and I will drive hours to sit across a table from someone when possible and appropriate. Anyone who wants to hold me to account knows exactly where to find me.

That has cost us. I wrote in The Glorious Few about the loneliness of this road. I wrote about evangelicals “who often refuse to extend the basic courtesy of listening, or even asking.” This exchange is a textbook example.

Now look at the other side. He posted as @mannajetzt. He told us about his upbringing in eastern Germany, but nothing of the church he belongs to or any office he holds. When the brother asked which church he belonged to and whether he held any office, the answer was “Brother! Stop please. Pray for the spirit of discernment.” He said he was “content to be known simply as a brother in Christ.”

So he names me in full and warns the world about me, and he won’t tell anyone who he is or who he answers to. He demands that everyone test me, and he won’t be tested himself.

Scripture has something to say about that. “Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses” (1 Timothy 5:19). “The one who states his case first seems right, until the other comes and examines him” (Proverbs 18:17). A public charge against a named man, brought by an unnamed one, who has read almost nothing, with no witnesses and no willingness to be examined, wouldn’t get past the door of any biblical court.

I’ve named his handle because his words were public, and the record should be public too. What I want you to see is the asymmetry. Faceless accusation costs nothing. Speaking under your own name, in your own voice, with your wife’s name beside yours, costs a great deal. The internet is full of the first kind of courage and very short of the second.

The frank and manly Mr Ryle

I take comfort in the men who went before.

In 1868 J. C. Ryle was called“the frank and manly Mr Ryle.” Iain Murray titled his biography of him Prepared to Stand Alone. Ryle spent his life saying unpopular things under his own name, and he knew exactly what it would cost. He wrote that anyone who speaks plainly about false doctrine “must be content to find himself thought very uncharitable, very troublesome, and very narrow-minded.”

He also wrote: “There is a hatred which is downright charity – that is the hatred of erroneous doctrine.” And when ministers will not preach “all the counsel of God,” Ryle’s counsel was blunt: “you ought to cease to hear them.” Nobody calls Ryle a cult leader. They call him a giant. But if he were alive today with a YouTube channel, I suspect he’d be getting the same comments I get.

Judged by the standard he quotes

His main texts against me are John 7:24, “Do not judge according to appearance,” and Romans 14, “Who are you to judge the servant of another?”

He says I’m driven by “a personal grievance.” He says I speak “out of woundedness rather than the Holy Spirit,” (see here on this old, lazy trope) and that my ministry “thrives on pointing fingers at the flock.” He applies Acts 20:30 to me, which is Paul’s warning about men who rise up to draw away disciples after themselves.

Every one of those is a judgment about my heart and motives, and none of them could be seen in three items. He accused me of judging thousands of hearts from a few comments, then he judged mine from a few documents.

About Acts 20:30: I don’t call anyone to follow me. The Glorious Few gives a recommendation for prayer at the end of every chapter, and its appendix is an open letter on how to assess whether your church is faithful by the standard of 2 Timothy. The test is Scripture, not Nick Franks. The message is to seek God, not men.

Cult, sect, or isolation?

He says I’m building “an elitist filter-bubble,” a “cult-like” group cut off in “virtual exile.” Again, he’s describing a book he hasn’t read.

Chapter seven of The Glorious Few deals with exactly this question. I set out the difference between a church, a sect and a cult, and I warn that “an ‘unorthodox’ view does not necessarily mean a heretical (or cultic) one.” I wrote that chapter because the charge he’s making is the first one thrown at anyone the Holy Spirit leads out of systemic, institutionalised compromise.

On isolation, I wrote this: “we cannot make communities of radicalised disciples in long-term isolation and neither do I think primarily in digital/online spaces. We need to straighten out in floored humility together.”

So yes, I call God’s people out of compromised institutions. I’ve never hidden that, and neither did Ryle. But I call them toward each other, in person, under Christ. That isn’t a filter bubble. It’s the church and it is a supernatural miracle.

Save us, O LORD our God, and gather us from among the nations, that we may give thanks to your holy name and glory in your praise. (Psalm 106:47)

The zombies

Now to the words he objects to most. He says I called brothers and sisters “mindless, raging zombies,” and that this is the modern equivalent of “Raca” and “fool” in Matthew 5:22.

I’m not going to soften it. I stand by the picture and every word around it.

I opened that video with a scene from I Am Legend, where the infected bang their heads against the glass in an unrelenting, unreasonable, irrational rage. I said the comments I’d been receiving were like that. They were. And I said the rage wasn’t simply bad manners. I believe it is demonic, as all false teaching that misrepresents the Lord is. It’s the rage of a spirit that despises and dismisses the work of the Holy Spirit. And notice that the story in that film is about a cure.

When you name a spirit, you aren’t insulting a person. You’re identifying the enemy. Paul says we wrestle not against flesh and blood but against spiritual forces of evil (Ephesians 6:12). Jesus looked at Peter, his own disciple, and said “Get behind me, Satan,” because Peter’s thinking had become the devil’s (Matthew 16:23). Was Jesus “dehumanising” Peter? No. He was telling him the truth about where those words came from.

And I didn’t call those commenters brothers. I called them “so-called Christians,” and I asked whether that fruit comes from the new birth. He assumes they’re brothers and then accuses me of insulting brothers. That assumes the very thing in dispute.

As for Matthew 5:22, the word Jesus forbids there is “fool,” moros in the Greek. In Matthew 23:17 Jesus uses that same word for the Pharisees: “fools and blind.” He called them whitewashed tombs and a brood of vipers. Paul wrote “O foolish Galatians,” and “beware of the dogs.” If Matthew 5:22 forbade every strong word, it would condemn Jesus and Paul. It forbids contempt for a brother. It doesn’t forbid war against error. Again, the ‘frank and manly’ J.C. Ryle knew that all too well.

Here’s the root of the disagreement. He measures me by the gentleness of Galatians 5. I believe in that gentleness. But in The Glorious Few I point out that Jesus’ gentleness and lowliness (Matthew 11:29) comes in the same passage where he praises John the Baptist’s spiritual violence (Matthew 11:12). “The kingdom of heaven has suffered violence, and the violent take it by force.” Jesus doesn’t set those against each other, and neither should he.

This is wartime. The context is eternity, not the reputations of men. The church doesn’t need more genteel vicars managing their brand on YouTube. It needs men who will say what God says, in the tone God uses, and take what comes. The other way is cowardice, and it’s how we got here.

Spiritual adultery and the antichrist spirit

His strongest charge is that I erase the line between primary and secondary doctrine, so that everything becomes “my way or apostasy.”

Those two phrases aren’t in my Confession, but I won’t hide behind that. I have called cessationism spiritual adultery in I AM JEALOUS, an eight-session teaching series and ebook on the jealousy of God for his bride. My accuser hasn’t read that either. The whole argument rests on one biblical fact: only a bride can commit spiritual adultery, by abandoning her Husband (Galatians 1:6).

“Spiritual adultery” isn’t a word for unbelievers. It’s the charge God brings against his own covenant people. “Son of man, make known to Jerusalem her abominations” (Ezekiel 16:2). Israel was the unfaithful wife, and she was still his wife. James writes “you adulteresses” to believers (James 4:4). Paul warns the Corinthian church that they’re provoking the Lord to jealousy (1 Corinthians 10:22). And he tells the Galatians they are “so quickly deserting him who called you” for a different gospel (Galatians 1:6). As Erik Thoennes shows in Godly Jealousy, Paul treated any failure of devotion to the true gospel as spiritual adultery and desertion of a spouse.

So when I call cessationism spiritual adultery, I’m not necessarily saying that cessationists aren’t Christians; I’m saying the bride has been unfaithful to her husband.

Nor is this partisan. In I AM JEALOUS I bring the same charge against egalitarianism, seeker-sensitivity and the prosperity gospels, and the last two are rife in the charismatic world. I wrote that the church, “especially the charismatics/seeker-sensitives,” is all over the place on God’s jealousy. I’m not defending a camp. I’m defending a marriage and therefore the honour of The Bridegroom.

As for the line between primary and secondary doctrine, he’s right that I reject it as it’s used today. My Confession says those categories have “functioned not as a safeguard of truth, but as scaffolding for sustained contradiction.” In a marriage there’s no such thing as secondary faithfulness. Thoennes puts it simply: idolatry is putting anything above God or equal to him.

Then there’s “antichrist.” That word isn’t in my Confession either. In my video I spoke of “an antichrist despising” that goes with the false teaching of cessationism, and I stand by it. He says 1 John 4 defines antichrist only as denying the incarnation, so it can’t apply to a debate about gifts. But read 1 John 2. John speaks of antichrists in verse 18. Two verses later he says, “you have an anointing from the Holy One” (2:20). The word antichrist is built on Christ, the Anointed One, and John sets it right beside the anointing the Spirit gives believers (2:27).

My concern was never a quarrel about gifts. It’s a spirit that despises and dismisses the work of the Person of The Holy Spirit. In my video I called that “dishonoring and misrepresenting the Holy Spirit.” Only a joker would consider this as a secondary matter.

Jealous with His jealousy

He says I play the suffering martyr, and that true suffering is silent, “like a lamb before its shearers” (Isaiah 53:7).

Isaiah 53 describes Christ bearing our sins, the one place he opened not his mouth. It isn’t a rule that his servants must never answer. When an officer struck Jesus at his trial, he said, “If I have spoken evil, bear witness of the evil” (John 18:23). Paul defends himself through most of 2 Corinthians 10 to 13.

The Name of the LORD is Jealous (Exodus 34:14). Scripture has always had men who shared that jealousy, and it never made them popular, in fact it often carried with it fatal effects.

At Baal-peor, when Israel had given itself to idolatry and immorality and the plague had broken out, Phinehas “rose and left the congregation” and acted in full view of everyone (Numbers 25:7). God said he was “jealous with my jealousy” (Numbers 25:11), and gave him a covenant of peace. As Erik Thoennes puts it, Phinehas broke ranks with the passivity of the crowd. He didn’t send a warning from the back of the crowd without giving his name. He stood up in front of everyone.

Let me be clear, because someone will twist this. I hold no spear, and the New Testament hands none to anyone. “The weapons of our warfare are not of the flesh,” Paul says, “but have divine power to destroy strongholds” (2 Corinthians 10:4). He quoted that very passage at the brother from Scotland. It cuts the other way. Our warfare is spiritual, our weapon is the word of God, and the jealousy is God’s own.

David knew what that jealousy costs. “Zeal for your house has consumed me, and the reproaches of those who reproach you have fallen on me” (Psalm 69:9). The disciples remembered that verse when Jesus cleared the temple (John 2:17). The reproach comes because of the zeal. Jesus promised it: “If they persecuted me, they will also persecute you”(John 15:20).

I’m not claiming to be a martyr. I’m saying this is exactly what Scripture says happens to anyone who speaks for the honour of God’s Name. Answering isn’t pride. Saying nothing would be.

The brother who answered him

He also turned on the brother from Scotland who answered him, and then folded that brother into his verdict on me. He called the brother’s attitude “the exact elitist mindset that Nick is promoting.”

That brother spoke for himself, and he said so:“I don’t completely know what Nick meant by zombies, so it would be up to him to clarify,” and “I’m certainly not Nick’s cheerleader or watchdog.” His words are his to answer for. Mine are mine.

But look at how he was treated. He asked for patient reasoning, shared his testimony, and offered the book and a meeting. He was thanked for a “friendly and thoughtful” reply. The warmth lasted until he asked which church his critic belonged to and what office he held.

The brother described years of conscience and prayer and being pushed out of a church, and the reply was a diagnosis: “past wounds,” a “virtual exile.” The brother said he meets locally with other believers, and the final rebuttal ignored it. The harshest charges came in a closing statement that announced he wouldn’t engage any further. Hit, then run.

In the video I said this spirit sometimes wears a more respectable veneer. Here that meant gentle words, blessings and doves, together with refusing to be questioned and taking the last word. You can read the exchange for yourself.

What he conceded

What I find most telling is what he agreed with:

  • The concerns about the direction of the churches are “justified.”
  • God can use global crises to discipline his church. He called that “a valid biblical discussion.”
  • Whether a church meets in a building or a home is irrelevant.
  • Jesus holds his church to non-negotiable standards, as Revelation shows.
  • It is “often spiritually wise—and even necessary—to steer clear of certain compromised congregations.”
  • The Lord removes the lampstands of unfaithful, apostate congregations.

That’s most of what I’ve been saying. He never answered the argument of God Closed Church, that closing the churches was God’s judgment on his own house and that his people must hear what he’s saying through it. He never read The Glorious Few or I AM JEALOUS. He argued with my tone and with two phrases he wrongly attributed to my Confession, and called the rest dangerous.

An invitation

So here’s my invitation, to him and to anyone who shares his concern. Do what he told everyone else to do and test all things. Read The Glorious Few and God Closed Church. Work through I AM JEALOUS. Then put your name to your objections, quote me in context, and show me from Scripture where I’m wrong. If I am, I will say so publicly and openly not from within the cowardly infantile shadows of YouTube.

Until then, an anonymous warning about calls to action the accused hasn’t called for, built on skewing words used within a study on the LORD Whose Name is Jealous, isn’t a test.

I say all this with no ill will toward him. Paul called this kind of self-defence foolishness, “I have been a fool! You forced me to it,” and he did it “all for your upbuilding” (2 Corinthians 12:11, 19). I answer for the same reason. If he reads this, he is welcome at the table, and I would gladly spend and be spent for his soul as for yours, (2 Corinthians 12:15).

Maranatha.

Related Content

Published by firebrandnotes

"Radically preparing for the Return of Christ." If you long for the return of Christ and are distressed by the chaos of the Church, please read my books, Body Zero (2019), The Glorious Few (2023), and God Closed Church (2024).

One thought on “Drive-By Discernment”

  1. If anybody knew you ( and Mari) they’d know your heart motivation, they’d know the cost of what you declare in the public space and the price you’ve paid to be where you are in your journey as a Christ Follower. They would know that paddling against the current, so to speak, comes with great risk. You are called to declare the good news of the Kingdom of God and salvation in Yeshua alone. It will be YOU who stands before Adonai when He asks of you “What did you do Nick with what I asked you to do?” Akin to Matthew 25 the talents. He is purposeful to trust us to do with what He has entrusted to us, in the expectation that we should do our best FOR HIS KINGDOM benefit. I know you take your calling seriously, in spite of the criticism, within and without of the Bride of Christ, and especially that influenced by the Unseen Realm. Keep your spirit pure, keep your eyes on the prize, who IS Jesus…and may your chosen words be arrows that peirce the darkness to tje Glory of God. You ARE loved and valued.

Leave a Reply